Use this coupon on your first purchase and get a 5% discount
TRUTH5
In an increasingly competitive gastropub market, where margins are tight and customers have endless options just a click away, finding ways to increase the average check without losing customers is the holy grail of profitability. Most owners immediately think of raising prices, adding expensive dishes to the menu, or pushing premium drinks. But there's a much more subtle and effective strategy that often goes unnoticed: making olive oil the star of your menu.
Premium extra virgin olive oil, when presented and managed correctly, is not just another operating expense: it's a strategic value-generating tool. Verdedad, with its first-pressed, cold-extracted Picual olive oil from Jaén olive groves, allows gastropubs to create distinctive dishes, justify price increases, generate natural upselling, and build a brand identity that attracts customers willing to pay more for authentic quality. This article shows you exactly how to transform a bottle of oil into a revenue-generating machine per table without forcing sales or compromising the customer experience.
Why premium oil increases the average transaction value
Before we get into specific tactics, let's understand the psychology behind why a seemingly simple product like oil can have such a significant impact on how much each customer spends.
Premium olive oil acts as an anchor for perceived value. When a customer sees that your gastropub uses Verdedad olive oil with its Lion of Truth seal, clearly originating from olive groves in Jaén, and produced using a transparent process (first pressing, cold extraction), their brain immediately infers: "If they take such care with the oil, which many establishments ignore, I can only imagine the attention they pay to everything else." This heightened perception of overall quality mentally justifies higher prices across your entire menu.
Furthermore, premium olive oil allows you to create tangible differentiation. In a sea of gastropubs offering virtually identical toasts, platters, and salads, the oil becomes your distinguishing feature. It's not "just another tomato toast," it's "our toast with Verdedad Picual olive oil from Jaén." This specificity communicates exclusivity and justifies a higher price than the competition.
The oil also facilitates non-aggressive upselling. It's easier for a waiter to suggest, "Would you like to finish your burrata with a drizzle of our Verdedad oil?" than to push an additional dish. The customer perceives this as an enhancement to their current experience, not a forced sale, and is more receptive.
Finally, premium oil generates organic social media content. Verdedad's bottles, especially the handcrafted ceramic one, are highly photogenic. When your customers upload photos mentioning your special oil, you're building a reputation for a shop that pays attention to detail, attracting a more affluent clientele willing to spend more for a quality experience.
The numbers confirm it: gastropubs that have incorporated premium EVOO as a differentiating element report increases in average ticket between 12-18% in the first quarter, mainly due to increases in the price of existing dishes and a greater propensity of the customer to ask for extras and recommendations from the staff.
Strategy 1: Create your premium toast line
Toast is the star product in most gastropubs: high profit margin, quick to prepare, perfect for sharing. But it's also the most commoditized product: everyone has toast, and they're all similar. Verdedad oil allows you to transform it into a differentiated premium product.
Instead of offering a generic "toast with tomato," create a Verdedad toast section on your menu. Each toast in this line is served with extra virgin Picual olive oil, finished tableside by the server. The ritual is simple yet effective: the toast leaves the kitchen without oil, the server arrives with the Verdedad bottle, briefly explains its origin in Jaén, and finishes the dish in front of the customer.
This little theatrical display has several effects: it increases perceived value (personalized service), educates the customer about the olive oil (preparing them for future purchases), creates a memorable moment (experience vs. transaction), and justifies a price 20-30% higher than your standard toast. If your basic tomato toast costs €4, your "Verdedad Toast with seasonal tomato and Picual olive oil from Jaén" can be perfectly positioned at €5.50.
Develop 4-5 premium toasts in this line: avocado with Verdedad oil and seeds, goat cheese with honey and Picual olive oil, salmon with oil and chives, and Iberian ham with grated tomato and Jaén olive oil. They all share the common element (Verdedad oil) that creates the line's identity, but each offers variety.
The impact on the average order value is direct: if a customer previously ordered two basic toasts (€8), they now order two Verdedad toasts (€11). Multiply that by 50 tables per day, and you're generating an additional €150 daily, more than €4,500 per month, simply by optimizing your toast offerings with premium olive oil.
The key is the communication on the menu. Don't just write "with Verdedad oil" in small print. Highlight it: "Finished with Verdedad extra virgin olive oil, Picual variety from Jaén, first pressing." Specificity sells. The customer understands they're paying for something real, not empty marketing.
Strategy 2: Sharing boards with oil as the main feature
Sharing platters are pure gold for the average check: they're usually the highest-margin item on the menu, are ordered in groups (increasing the number of items per table), and create a social experience that customers value. Truthfulness can become the central element that elevates your platters from good to exceptional.
Design a "Verdedad Platter" where the oil isn't just an accompaniment: it's the star. The composition could include: toasted artisan bread (3-4 varieties), seasonal cherry tomatoes, quality olives, semi-cured Manchego cheese, a small bowl of Verdedad for dipping, and the Verdedad Ceramic Bottle in the center of the platter as a visual and functional element.
This board doesn't cost €12 like your standard cheese board. It costs €18-22 because you're selling an experience and education. The customer doesn't just eat: they learn about quality olive oil, experiment with different combinations (bread with just oil, tomato with oil, cheese with oil), and leave with valuable knowledge.
Instruct your staff to present the platter with ceremony: "I bring you our Verdedad Platter. In the center is Picual olive oil from Jaén, first cold-pressed. I recommend trying it first with just the bread to appreciate its character, and then experimenting with the tomato and cheese." This knowledgeable service transforms an €8 cost product into one you sell for €20 without the customer feeling they are overpaying.
Calculate the impact: if you sell 15 Verdedad Platters daily at €20 each instead of 15 standard platters at €12 each, you generate an additional €120 per day. That's an extra €3,600 per month from a single product. And since the platters are typically ordered with drinks (wine, craft beer), the average order value for these platters increases even further.
Another approach is to offer an olive oil tasting experience (even if you only have Verdedad, you can present it with different pairings). Serve three small portions of Verdedad olive oil with three different accompaniments: tomato, garlic bread, and dark chocolate. Present this as a tasting experience. Price: €8-10. Actual cost: less than €2. Huge profit margin and a delighted customer who "discovered" the olive oil.
Platters featuring premium olive oil also generate massive social media buzz. They're visually stunning, especially with the ceramic bottle as the centerpiece. Your customers will photograph, share, and tag your establishment. This free marketing also positions your gastropub as a place for experiences, not just quick consumption.
Strategy 3: Upselling at the time of order
Effective upselling doesn't feel like aggressive sales tactics; it feels like helpful service. Verdedad provides you with the perfect tools for your staff to perform natural upselling that increases the average order value without inconveniencing the customer.
Train your team in three types of oil suggestions that consistently work. First: "Enhance your dish." When a customer orders salad, burrata, carpaccio, or any dish that typically includes oil, the server suggests: "Would you like us to finish it with our Verdedad Picual olive oil from Jaén? It completely elevates the flavor." You charge an extra €2 for this service. Actual cost: 30 cents worth of oil. The customer perceives value because they see the service ritual and because the server has explained the origin.
Second suggestion: "Try our bread with Verdedad." When a table arrives and orders drinks, before they order food, offer: "Would you like to start with our artisanal bread with tomato and Verdedad olive oil while you decide?" It's a mid-range starter (€4-5) that almost no one refuses because it's tempting, inexpensive, and "while we decide" sounds reasonable. Multiply that by 30 tables a day, and that's an extra €120-150.
Third suggestion: "Take the experience home." At the end of the service, after the customer has enjoyed the oil, the waiter says, "Did you like our oil? You can take a bottle home to enjoy." If you sell 5 bottles a week (perfectly achievable), you generate additional income without any marketing effort.
The key to successful upselling is timing and framing. You don't offer premium oil when the customer is looking at prices and calculating. You offer it when they've already decided to eat at your establishment, when they're relaxed, when they've tasted the oil and liked it. And you present it as an enhancement to their experience, not as an additional cost.
Encourage your staff to make these suggestions. A simple system: for every 10 "oil enhancements" sold, the server receives a €5 bonus. This costs little (considering the oil margin) but greatly motivates the team to actively suggest. Your average check increases, your team earns more, and the customer receives a better experience. Everyone wins.
Measure results weekly. Calculate how many oil suggestions are made versus how many are accepted. A 40% acceptance rate is excellent and realistic when staff are well-trained. If your gastropub serves 200 covers per week and you get 40% of customers to accept a €2 oil upgrade, you generate an additional €160 per week, almost €700 per month, from upselling alone.
Strategy 4: Create signature dishes where the oil is the hero
Every successful gastropub has 2-3 signature dishes: those that everyone orders, that go viral on social media, that define the establishment's identity. Verdedad allows you to create signature dishes where the olive oil is the undisputed hero, generating a differentiation impossible to replicate without the same product.
Develop a "Verdedad Ajoblanco" if your gastropub has a Mediterranean or Andalusian flair. Ajoblanco (a cold soup of almonds, garlic, and olive oil) lives or dies by the quality of the oil. Made with Verdedad Picual olive oil, it has a depth and character that versions with mediocre oil never achieve. Serve it in a wide bowl, with white grapes, slivered almonds, and a generous final splash of Verdedad that the waiter adds tableside. Price: €8-9. It's an experience, a visual spectacle, and authentic flavor.
Another option is "Verdedad Broken Eggs." This most Spanish and popular dish in gastropubs is elevated to a whole new level when the oil used to fry the potatoes and eggs is premium Picual olive oil. The robust character of Verdedad adds a dimension that neutral oils simply can't provide. State this on your menu: "Broken eggs with Iberian ham, fried in Verdedad Picual olive oil from Jaén." The customer understands there's a real difference, not just marketing hype.
One dish that works brilliantly: "Burrata with seasonal tomato, basil, and Verdedad." Burrata is a premium product that justifies the high price, but what makes the dish memorable is the oil. The burrata is served without oil, and when it arrives at the table, the waiter theatrically opens it and generously tops it with Verdedad while briefly explaining its origin. The customer pays €14-16 for this dish and perceives it as an accessible luxury.
Signature dishes featuring olive oil as the star ingredient offer several commercial advantages. First, they are more profitable : the profit margin on olive oil is high, even when using premium extra virgin olive oil. Second, they are difficult to replicate : competitors can copy your recipe, but without Verdedad, the result won't be the same. Third, they generate customer loyalty : customers return specifically looking for "that dish with the special oil."
When designing these dishes, think Instagram. The presentation must be photogenic: contrasting colors, height in the plating, that final drizzle of golden oil. A dish that generates 50 photos on social media each month is free advertising worth hundreds of euros.
Strategy 5: Customer education for conscious consumption
Customers who understand what they're consuming are willing to pay more. It's that simple. That's why natural wine costs more than generic wine, and why single-origin coffee costs more than blended coffee. Educating your clientele about olive oil turns them into conscious consumers who value and pay for quality.
Implement "olive oil tasting nights" once a month. Simple format: 20 places, 8:00-9:30 pm, €25 per person. The format includes: a brief talk about olive oil (10 minutes), a guided tasting of Verdedad olive oil with different pairings (20 minutes), and then a light 3-course dinner where olive oil is the star (60 minutes). Operating cost: low (you use existing products, cook simple dishes). Benefit: threefold. First, direct income from the 20 places (€500). Second, education of 20 customers who become ambassadors for the olive oil and request more premium dishes on future visits. Third, content for social media and competitive differentiation.
Another educational tactic is the informational menu. Include a small box on your menu that explains: "In our gastropub, we exclusively use Verdedad olive oil, a Picual variety from olive groves in Jaén, first cold-pressed. The Lion of Truth guarantees authenticity in every drop." These 30 words completely elevate the perception. The customer understands that your commitment to quality is genuine.
Train your staff to be olive oil evangelists. Every server should be able to explain in 30 seconds what makes Verdedad special. They don't need to be olive oil experts: they just need to know the origin (Jaén), the variety (Picual), the process (first cold pressing), and the symbol (the Lion of Truth). With these four pieces of information, they can answer 90% of questions and create a perception of professionalism.
Create visual educational materials for your establishment. A small sign at the bar or entrance explaining the olive oil you use, with photos of olive groves in Jaén, information about the Picual variety, and the story of the Lion of Truth. Customers waiting for a table will read it, and by the time they sit down, they'll already be predisposed positively toward your offering.
Education also works after consumption. In your monthly newsletter (if you have one), dedicate a section to "Ingredient of the Month," rotating information about your premium products. One month it could be Verdedad olive oil, another your Iberian ham, another your seasonal tomatoes. You're building an informed clientele that values quality and is willing to pay fair prices for it.
The ROI of education is subtle but real. You can't attribute a specific increase of X euros to education alone. But gastropubs that invest in educating their clientele report a higher percentage of customers ordering premium dishes, less resistance to higher prices, and greater customer loyalty. These are customers who understand that paying €6 for toast with Verdedad olive oil is value, not an expense.
Strategy 6: Loyalty program with oil as a reward
Loyalty programs work when the reward is desirable and relevant. A bottle of Verdedad is the perfect reward for a regular gastropub customer : it has real value, it's a product they already know and appreciate, and it's useful (they take it home and every time they use it, they're reminded of your establishment).
Design a simple program: "10 visits, 1 free bottle of Verdedad." Every time a customer makes a purchase at your establishment, they get their loyalty card stamped. On their tenth visit, they receive a free glass bottle of Verdedad. The cost to you is moderate (one bottle for every 10 visits from a customer who typically spends €20-25 per visit = a cost of 10-12% of that revenue). The benefit is enormous: you build customer loyalty, ensure they return 10 times, and provide them with a product that constantly reinforces a positive association with your brand.
A more sophisticated alternative: a points system. Every euro spent = 1 point. 500 points = a bottle of Verdedad. 1000 points = dinner for two with olive oil pairings. This gamifies the experience and encourages spending more on each visit to accumulate points faster.
Offering oil as a loyalty reward has an advantage over discounts: it doesn't degrade price perception. When you give a 10% discount as a reward, you're implicitly saying, "Our prices have room to go down." When you give a premium product, you're saying, "We value your loyalty and reward you with the best we have." The message is completely different.
Furthermore, the complimentary Verdedad olive oil generates future sales. The customer takes it home, uses it, and gets used to the quality. When it runs out, they want more. They come back to buy it at your gastropub or ask where to get it. You've created demand for a high-margin product without any marketing effort.
Actively promote your loyalty program. At each table, next to the bill, leave a card explaining: "Are you a regular customer? Join our Verdedad program and get free premium oil." The sign-up rate will be high because the reward is tangible and desirable, not abstract like "future discounts."
Strategy 7: Private events and premium catering
Private events (birthdays, corporate celebrations, meetings) are a golden opportunity for mid-to-high-end business. Verdedad oil allows you to position your gastropub for premium catering where margins are significantly higher than for regular service.
When designing menus for events, create a "Verdedad Option" that is 15-20% more expensive than your base menu. The difference: all cold dishes are finished with Verdedad oil served tableside, you include a mini oil tasting as an appetizer, and each guest takes home a small 100ml bottle of Verdedad as a souvenir of the event. The additional cost to you is moderate, but the perceived value for the corporate or private client organizing the event is enormous.
Corporate events especially value differentiating elements. When a company is looking for a venue for a team dinner, the decision is rarely based solely on price: it's about creating a memorable experience that the organizer can boast about. "We had dinner at X gastrobar and they prepared a special menu for us, including an olive oil tasting from Jaén" is a much better story than "we went out for dinner."
Develop catering packages for takeaway where Verdedad takes center stage. "Andalusian Pack": 20 premium canapés, 2 glass bottles of Verdedad, artisanal bread, tomatoes, and ceramic serving bowls. Price: €180-200. This high-perceived-value product is perfect for office meetings or home celebrations. Your profit margin is excellent, and the customer is happy to pay because they're buying a unique experience.
When catering events, always bring bottles of Verdedad in plain sight. Don't hide them in the kitchen: leave them on the serving table and use them in front of your guests. This sparks conversation ("What kind of oil is that?"), positions your brand as premium, and often results in new customers who want to visit your gastropub after trying your food at the event.
Events featuring Verdedad also generate content. Incentivize the organizer: "If you share photos of the event mentioning our Verdedad oil on social media, we'll give you a 10% discount on your next event." This turns each event into a marketing generator that attracts more future events.
Calculating the real ROI: numbers that add up
Let's talk concrete numbers so you can see exactly how Verdedad oil impacts your bottom line. We're going to calculate the ROI for an average gastropub serving 80 covers per day.
Baseline scenario (without premium oil): Current average check: €18 per person. Daily revenue: €1,440. Monthly revenue: €43,200. Your menu includes toast for €4, platters for €12, and salads for €9. All served with generic oil that no one notices or appreciates.
Verdedad Scenario (implementing strategies from this article): You create a premium toast line at €5.50. 40% of customers who previously ordered basic toast (16 people daily) now order Verdedad toast. Increase: €24 daily, €720 monthly. You implement the Verdedad Platter at €20. You sell 10 daily (previously you sold 10 standard platters at €12). Increase: €80 daily, €2,400 monthly. Your staff upsells "upgrade with oil" (+€2) and it's accepted by 30% of tables (24 people). Increase: €48 daily, €1,440 monthly.
Partial sums from just these three tactics: an additional €152 daily, €4,560 monthly. Your average ticket has increased from €18 to €20.20. That's a 12.2% increase without adding a single table, without expensive marketing campaigns, simply by optimizing the value of each customer you already have.
Now subtract the cost of the Verdedad oil. With glass bottles, your cost per serving is minimal. Even being generous with the product, the additional cost of implementing these strategies is approximately €600-€800 per month in oil. Your additional monthly net profit: €3,760-€3,960. Annualized: €45,000-€47,500 more profit.
These figures are conservative. They don't include: takeaway bottle sales, private events with premium menus, increased beverage consumption (customers who order premium dishes tend to order better wines), or the effect of organic marketing (new customers attracted by a reputation for quality). If you include these side effects, the real impact could be a 20-25% increase in total revenue.
The initial investment is minimal: purchasing Verdedad bottles, some staff training, menu adjustments. You recoup your investment in the first two weeks. From then on, it's pure profit that accumulates month after month, year after year.
Mistakes to avoid when implementing
Implementing premium oil as a mid-range ticket strategy can backfire if you make these mistakes. Learn from others to avoid repeating them.
Mistake 1: Buying premium olive oil but not communicating it. If you invest in Verdedad but your menu simply says "with olive oil," you've wasted your money. The customer doesn't know the difference, doesn't value the product, and isn't willing to pay more. Always communicate: origin, variety, and production process. Without communication, there is no perceived value.
Mistake 2: Staff who don't know about the oil. If your servers can't explain what makes Verdedad special, upselling opportunities die before they even begin. Invest 30 minutes in training your team. The difference in results is enormous.
Mistake 3: Being stingy with the product. Some owners buy premium oil and then use it sparingly to "maximize profit margin." Fatal mistake. Oil should be used generously so the customer can truly appreciate its quality. The profit margin comes from the sales volume of premium dishes, not from saving 10ml of oil per dish.
Mistake 4: Raising prices without improving the experience. You can't simply add "with Verdedad oil" to the dish's name, raise the price by €2, and expect it to work. You must improve the presentation, add a service ritual, and educate the customer. The price increase must correspond to a real increase in value.
Error 5: Inconsistency. If one day you serve Verdedad and the next, because you ran out or to save money, you go back to generic oil, you destroy all trust. Customers will notice the difference and feel cheated. Once you promise a specific quality, you must deliver it consistently.
Mistake 6: Forgetting to rotate stock. Olive oil, even premium, has a best-before date. If you buy a lot and then use it slowly, the oil loses freshness. It's better to buy more frequently in reasonable quantities than to accumulate stock that degrades. It's very important to store it under the right conditions.
Error 7: Not measuring results. You implement changes but don't measure average order value before and after, you don't know which dishes are successful, and you don't optimize. Without measurement, there is no improvement. Keep weekly track of average order value, sales per dish, and feedback received. The data will tell you what works and what to adjust.
30-day implementation plan
You have the theory, you have the strategies. Now you need a concrete action plan to implement Verdedad in your gastropub and start seeing results. Here's your 30-day roadmap.
Week 1: Preparation and training. Days 1-2: Place your Verdedad order (a pack of glass bottles and at least one ceramic bottle for testing). Days 3-4: When the oil arrives, organize a tasting session with your entire team. Let them taste it, appreciate its quality, and understand what makes it special. Days 5-7: Develop your new line of premium dishes. Test recipes, adjust presentations, calculate costs and prices. Define what will be on the new menu.
Week 2: Design and Communication. Days 8-10: Redesign a relevant section of your menu, incorporating Verdedad dishes. Ensure the information about the olive oil is clear and prominent. Days 11-12: Create visual materials for the restaurant (poster explaining Verdedad, photo of olive groves in Jaén, story of the Lion). Days 13-14: Train your staff in presentation and upselling techniques. Role-play scenarios until they feel comfortable.
Week 3: Soft Launch. Days 15-17: Introduce the new Verdedad dishes, but only to regular and receptive customers. Ask for honest feedback. Adjust what isn't working. Days 18-20: Start implementing upselling suggestions with oil. Measure the acceptance rate. If it's less than 30%, review how your staff is making the suggestion. Day 21: Take stock of the first week. Calculate the average check for tables that ordered Verdedad dishes versus standard tables.
Week 4: Full Launch and Optimization. Days 22-24: Officially launch the complete Verdedad line to all customers. Promote on social media with professional photos of your new dishes. Days 25-27: Host your first "olive oil tasting night" if you decided to implement that strategy. Use the event to generate content and educate customers. Days 28-30: Measure results for the entire month. Compare average order value before vs. after, sales per dish, and customer feedback. Identify what works best and what needs adjusting.
Starting on the 31st, you're in continuous optimization mode. Each week, review the numbers, adjust strategies, and test new ideas. Verdedad oil is a tool, but your consistent execution and continuous improvement are what transform that tool into a revenue-generating machine.
Verdad: your partner in profitability
You've seen the strategies. You've seen the numbers. You've seen that increasing average order value doesn't require complicated tricks or massive investments: it requires an exceptional product used intelligently. Verdedad is that product.
Our extra virgin olive oil from Jaén olive groves, Picual variety, first cold-pressed, is not just another ingredient for your kitchen. It's a strategic tool for differentiation and value creation. The Lion of Truth seal on each bottle is your visible ally in the fight to stand out in a market saturated with indistinguishable gastropubs.
We offer two formats designed for the specific needs of gastropubs:
Perfect for everyday use in the kitchen and for table service. Dark vinyl-coated glass keeps the oil in optimal condition. Non-refillable cap that meets regulations. Understated design that complements any setting. Enough quantity to implement all the strategies for using this product without worrying about running out of stock. It's your go-to for premium toast, charcuterie boards, upselling, and signature dishes.
Your visual statement piece for special platters, private events, and Instagram moments. Handcrafted items that your customers will photograph and share. Perfect for your Verdedad Platter, olive oil tastings, or as a centerpiece that defines your gastropub's identity, where attention to detail is key. An investment that pays for itself through social media content and brand differentiation.
Both formats contain authentic olive oil: Picual from Jaén, first pressed, cold-extracted. No blends, no shortcuts, no compromises. Green for its color. Truth for what it represents. The Lion of Truth guarantees that what you promise on the menu is what you deliver on the table.
We're not asking you to trust empty promises. We're asking you to run the numbers, like those in this article, using your own data. Calculate the value of a 12-15% increase in average transaction value for your gastropub. Then compare that number with the investment in Verdedad. The numbers add up. They always do when you offer real value.
Thousands of gastropubs worldwide already use premium olive oil as a profitability strategy. Those that do it right (quality product + clear communication + consistent execution) report results that transform their businesses. It's not magic: it's understanding that customers happily pay for authentic experiences when they know what they're getting.
Is your gastropub ready to increase average ticket price with authenticity?
Start with Truth:
• Pack of Glass Bottles - For implementing daily strategies
• Ceramic Bottle - For moments of maximum impact
• Fast international shipping
• Support material for staff training
• Implementation advice
The oil isn't an operating expense. It's an investment in differentiation, in experience, in brand identity. It's the difference between being just another gastropub and being the gastropub everyone remembers for that special oil.
Verdad. Verde. Verdad. Jaén. On your menu. Raising your average check. One bottle at a time.
Place your order today. Your numbers next month will thank you.
